Day 108 of 120 Speed Difficulty 8/10

Automatization is retrieval beating rule-based computation

Quick answer

Automatization is retrieval beating rule-based computation. Today's question (Instance theory of automatization) asks about a finding from Logan, G. D. in 1988. The correct option is A shift from rule-based computation to direct retrieval of stored instances of past solutions — full explanation, primary source, and glossary cross-links below.

Today's question

Logan's (1988) instance theory proposes that the speed-up with practice on tasks like alphabet arithmetic comes from:

  1. A A gradual rule-based algorithm that simply runs faster after practice
  2. B A shift from rule-based computation to direct retrieval of stored instances of past solutions
  3. C A pure muscle-memory effect with no cognitive component
  4. D Random guessing that accidentally lands faster
Reveal the answer and explanation

Correct: B — A shift from rule-based computation to direct retrieval of stored instances of past solutions

Logan (1988) argued that automatization is a memory phenomenon: each successful encounter with a problem stores a specific instance, and at test the system races algorithm against retrieval, with the faster process winning. Power-law speed-ups emerge naturally because the minimum of an increasing sample of independent retrieval times decays as a power function of practice. The theory unified data on visual search, alphabet arithmetic, and the Stroop task and predicted hallmark signatures: increasing variance ratios, transfer that depends on item-specific repetition, and dissociations between trained and untrained items even within the same task type.

About the source

Logan, G. D. (1988). Toward an instance theory of automatization. Psychological Review, 95(4), 492–527.

Every Cognition Bible question cites a primary source — a paper, book chapter, or monograph that exists, that we can point to on Google Scholar, and whose finding the question accurately summarizes. No fabricated authority strings, no name-drops without paper-level grounding.

More from the Cognition Bible

Done with today's question? Play the FOKIQ Daily — six puzzles across six cognitive domains, free, every day.